Abstract

Context: Conformance between architecture and implementation is a key aspect of architecture-centric development. Unfortunately, the architecture “as documented” and the architecture “as implemented” tend to diverge from each other over time. As this gap gets wider, the architects’ reliance on architecture-level analyses is compromised. Thus, conformance checks should be run periodically on the system in order to detect and correct differences. In practice, tool support is very beneficial for these checks.

Objective: Despite having a structural conformance analysis, assessing whether the main scenarios describing the architectural behavior are faithfully implemented in the code is still challenging. Checking conformance to architectural scenarios is usually a time-consuming and error-prone activity. In this article, we describe a tool approach called ArchSync that helps architects to reconcile a scenario-based architectural description with its source code, as changes are being made on the code.

Method: The architecture is specified with Use-Case Maps (UCMs), a notation for modeling both high-level structure and behavior. ArchSync applies heuristics that incrementally detect code deviations with respect to predetermined UCMs, based on the analysis of system execution traces for those UCMs. Also, ArchSync provides suggestions for re-synchronizing the UCMs with the code.

Results: We have evaluated a prototype of ArchSync in three medium-size case-studies, involving developers with moderate architecture experience. We compared time consumed, code browsed and suggestions for re-synchronizing the UCMs by these developers, with and without the support of ArchSync.

Conclusion: The results from case-studies and lessons learned have shown that the ArchSync approach is practical and reduces conformance checking efforts.

-- DanielAmyot - 16 Mar 2014

Discussion

FormForVirtualLibrary edit

Title Assisting conformance checks between architectural scenarios and implementation
Authors J.A. Díaz-Pace, Á. Soria, G. Rodríguez, M.R. Campo
Type Journal
Conference/Journal Title Information and Software Technology
Volume/Number 54(5)
Editors
Publisher Elsevier
Month May
Year 2012
Pages 448-466
DOI 10.1016/j.infsof.2011.12.005
Keywords Software architecture, Conformance checking, Behavioral scenarios, Tool support, UCMs, ArchSync
Topic revision: r1 - 16 Mar 2014, DanielAmyot
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Foswiki? Send feedback